Proposed experiment: an artificial ball lightning
(István Bencsik, scientific researcher, RS3 Informatics, November, 2026)
Abstract
This paper proposes an experimental setup to generate and investigate artificial ball lightning based on a Yukawa dusty plasma formed from nano- to micrometer-sized fly ash particles. Under an external electric field below 30 kV/cm, the fly ash cloud undergoes electrical breakdown at lower thresholds than clean air. By capturing fast electrons, the particles self-organize into an elastic, spherical plasma structure governed by Debye-screened Yukawa interactions and surface tension. Crucially, the external field is disconnected on a microsecond or nanosecond timescale using a high-speed switch to distinguish an externally sustained arc from a self-stabilizing plasma sphere. Once isolated, the sphere's lifespan is extended by negative differential resistance alongside exothermic chemical reactions involving carbon oxidation, carbon monoxide combustion, and hydroxyl radical recombination. To prevent wall-charge distortion, the setup specifies an insulated chamber sized at least 5–10 times the expected sphere diameter, operating at temperatures up to 4000 K (!). Size-fractionated fly ash and carbon-free quartz flour control measurements are proposed to separate purely electrostatic stabilization from chemical energy release. Diagnostics rely on high-speed cameras, photodiode arrays, and electrical antennas to record lifespan and high-frequency noise.
Keywords: artificial ball lightning, Yukawa dusty plasma, fly ash, negative differential resistance, Debye shielding, high-speed switching, plasma stabilization
Keywords: artificial ball lightning, Yukawa dusty plasma, fly ash, negative differential resistance, Debye shielding, high-speed switching, plasma stabilization
Introduction
On the role of negative differential resistance in ball lightning and formation of a ball lightning was discussed, as well. Particles within a positively charged cloud of fly ash spontaneously organize—via electron capture—into a stable, spherical structure, forming a Yukawa dusty plasma. Under high external electric field strength, the fly ash cloud undergoes electrical breakdown more readily than the surrounding air, creating a plasma. Once the external field ceases, the plasma sphere persists; its lifespan is extended—and the plasma itself stabilized—by negative differential resistance, allowing the phenomenon to endure for seconds or even minutes.
In the physical-mathematical modeling of ball lightning, the lifespan and stability of the plasma sphere present a challenge, even when energy losses are compensated by the combustion of a substance such as carbon. Stabilization is provided by the combustion of carbon monoxide and the dissociation of carbon dioxide—or, in the presence of water vapor, by the formation and recombination of hydroxyl radicals. Another—invariably present—stabilizing phenomenon is negative differential resistance. As the current within the plasma increases, the accelerating free electrons collide with neutral gas atoms with greater energy, liberating additional electron-ion pairs and thereby increasing the density of free charge carriers. The mechanism functions even in the absence of a DC component, which helps explain the observation that ball lightning can pass through closed windowpanes (dielectrics) or appear on their inner side without breaking them.
Proposed experiment: artificial ball lightning
A Yukawa dust plasma is generated within a chamber—subjected to an electric field strength of less than 30 kV/cm—using a cloud of nano- to micrometer-sized fly ash particles. Once a sphere has formed, the electric field is switched off using a high-speed switching mechanism. The stability duration is then measured under various conditions, such as the introduction of different impurities (e.g., water vapor, carbon). Rapid deactivation of the high-voltage field is crucial; it is the only way to distinguish an arc discharge—sustained by an external field—from a plasma sphere held together solely by internal forces (Yukawa potential and the release of chemical energy).
The electric field should be cut off using a high-voltage switch capable of operating on a microsecond or faster (nanosecond) timescale, ensuring that residual charge on the electrodes or inductive transients do not artificially sustain the discharge.
To measure the sphere's lifespan, it is recommended to use a high-speed camera and an array of photodiodes, supplemented by an electrical probe or antenna to record high-frequency current and voltage noise, as well as signals originating from negative differential resistance.
To ensure the reproducibility of the experiment, the fly ash particles should be filtered and fractionated by size, as both Debye shielding and the Yukawa potential are dependent on the specific surface area and mass of the particles. Before testing any pollutant, it is advisable to conduct a control measurement using clean, dry air or clean, carbon-free quartz flour. This allows for the quantification of chemical combustion versus the stability of a purely electrostatic dust plasma. The size of the chamber must be chosen carefully (at least 5–10 times the expected diameter of the sphere), and insulating walls should be used to prevent surface charges—which might accumulate on the walls—from distorting the internal equilibrium of the plasma sphere. The expected temperature of the sphere is ≤ 4000 K.
A Yukawa dust plasma is generated within a chamber—subjected to an electric field strength of less than 30 kV/cm—using a cloud of nano- to micrometer-sized fly ash particles. Once a sphere has formed, the electric field is switched off using a high-speed switching mechanism. The stability duration is then measured under various conditions, such as the introduction of different impurities (e.g., water vapor, carbon). Rapid deactivation of the high-voltage field is crucial; it is the only way to distinguish an arc discharge—sustained by an external field—from a plasma sphere held together solely by internal forces (Yukawa potential and the release of chemical energy).
The electric field should be cut off using a high-voltage switch capable of operating on a microsecond or faster (nanosecond) timescale, ensuring that residual charge on the electrodes or inductive transients do not artificially sustain the discharge.
To measure the sphere's lifespan, it is recommended to use a high-speed camera and an array of photodiodes, supplemented by an electrical probe or antenna to record high-frequency current and voltage noise, as well as signals originating from negative differential resistance.
To ensure the reproducibility of the experiment, the fly ash particles should be filtered and fractionated by size, as both Debye shielding and the Yukawa potential are dependent on the specific surface area and mass of the particles. Before testing any pollutant, it is advisable to conduct a control measurement using clean, dry air or clean, carbon-free quartz flour. This allows for the quantification of chemical combustion versus the stability of a purely electrostatic dust plasma. The size of the chamber must be chosen carefully (at least 5–10 times the expected diameter of the sphere), and insulating walls should be used to prevent surface charges—which might accumulate on the walls—from distorting the internal equilibrium of the plasma sphere. The expected temperature of the sphere is ≤ 4000 K.
*The Phenomenon of Negative Differential Resistance
This phenomenon occurs in certain non-linear electronic components and circuits within an operating range where the change in current flowing through the component and the change in the voltage applied across it have opposite signs: increasing the voltage causes the current to decrease, or increasing the current causes the voltage to drop—resulting in a negative differential resistance.
There are two main types, and negative differential resistance holds practical significance:
In the case of a voltage-controlled characteristic, the current is uniquely determined by a given voltage value; however, a single current value may correspond to three different voltage values (examples include tunnel diodes and tetrodes). Technical and circuit-related implications: negative differential resistance arises in arc discharges (such as lightning, arc welding, gas-discharge lamps, or electrical arcing faults). In electronic circuits, this phenomenon could lead to the immediate destruction of components, the blowing of fuses, or severe arc blasts; to prevent this, load or protective resistors—such as current-limiting ballasts or series impedances—are employed.
In the case of a current-controlled characteristic, an increase in current causes a sudden drop in the terminal voltage (examples include glow-discharge lamps, thyristors, or arc discharges). In the negative-resistance region, the component does not absorb energy; instead, it compensates for circuit losses using energy derived from the supply voltage, making it exceptionally well-suited for constructing high-frequency oscillators, signal amplifiers, and high-speed switching circuits. The instability resulting from this negative differential resistance generates characteristic high-frequency current and voltage noise associated with the electric arc. Modern arc-fault detection devices monitor the electrical network for these specific high-frequency signal patterns, allowing them to disconnect a faulty circuit before a fire can develop.
This phenomenon occurs in certain non-linear electronic components and circuits within an operating range where the change in current flowing through the component and the change in the voltage applied across it have opposite signs: increasing the voltage causes the current to decrease, or increasing the current causes the voltage to drop—resulting in a negative differential resistance.
There are two main types, and negative differential resistance holds practical significance:
In the case of a voltage-controlled characteristic, the current is uniquely determined by a given voltage value; however, a single current value may correspond to three different voltage values (examples include tunnel diodes and tetrodes). Technical and circuit-related implications: negative differential resistance arises in arc discharges (such as lightning, arc welding, gas-discharge lamps, or electrical arcing faults). In electronic circuits, this phenomenon could lead to the immediate destruction of components, the blowing of fuses, or severe arc blasts; to prevent this, load or protective resistors—such as current-limiting ballasts or series impedances—are employed.
In the case of a current-controlled characteristic, an increase in current causes a sudden drop in the terminal voltage (examples include glow-discharge lamps, thyristors, or arc discharges). In the negative-resistance region, the component does not absorb energy; instead, it compensates for circuit losses using energy derived from the supply voltage, making it exceptionally well-suited for constructing high-frequency oscillators, signal amplifiers, and high-speed switching circuits. The instability resulting from this negative differential resistance generates characteristic high-frequency current and voltage noise associated with the electric arc. Modern arc-fault detection devices monitor the electrical network for these specific high-frequency signal patterns, allowing them to disconnect a faulty circuit before a fire can develop.
**The ball lightning model (Bencsik, I., 2026. The interaction between fly ash and Yukawa plasma: ball lightning, DOI: 10.13140/RG.2.2.26392.15369) The model is built upon three main pillars:
Catalyzed arc discharge: In a strong external electric field, the presence of a cloud of nanoscale fly ash particles and silicate grains induces "tip effects" (field enhancement at sharp points) and "bridging effects" (chain formation). These phenomena initiate and sustain gas ionization—and thus an electric arc—at lower electric field strengths than would be required in air devoid of fly ash.
Cohesive Yukawa potential resulting in a spherical shape: Following the cessation of the external electric field (the afterglow phase), the fly ash particles acquire a significant negative charge by capturing fast electrons. Within the resulting non-thermal plasma, the interplay between Debye-screened repulsion (the Yukawa potential) and the surface energy/tension of the space-charge layers creates a fluid-like, elastic, spherical structure that remains stable even in the absence of an external field.
Non-linear feedback involving hydroxyl radicals, the dissociation of carbon dioxide into carbon monoxide, and the subsequent combustion of carbon and carbon monoxide serve to stabilize the temperature of the sphere. The slow surface oxidation (incandescence) of the carbon particles within the fly ash compensates for the energy lost through thermal and light radiation. Upon the emergence of the sphere—whether triggered by a preliminary discharge (leader) or an external force field—negative differential resistance contributes to its sudden formation, and the plasma sphere persists even after the external electric field has ceased. The explosive destruction of the structure is caused by the disruption of ionization equilibrium, followed by a global recombination avalanche.
Cohesive Yukawa potential resulting in a spherical shape: Following the cessation of the external electric field (the afterglow phase), the fly ash particles acquire a significant negative charge by capturing fast electrons. Within the resulting non-thermal plasma, the interplay between Debye-screened repulsion (the Yukawa potential) and the surface energy/tension of the space-charge layers creates a fluid-like, elastic, spherical structure that remains stable even in the absence of an external field.
Non-linear feedback involving hydroxyl radicals, the dissociation of carbon dioxide into carbon monoxide, and the subsequent combustion of carbon and carbon monoxide serve to stabilize the temperature of the sphere. The slow surface oxidation (incandescence) of the carbon particles within the fly ash compensates for the energy lost through thermal and light radiation. Upon the emergence of the sphere—whether triggered by a preliminary discharge (leader) or an external force field—negative differential resistance contributes to its sudden formation, and the plasma sphere persists even after the external electric field has ceased. The explosive destruction of the structure is caused by the disruption of ionization equilibrium, followed by a global recombination avalanche.
