Description of Bencsik ball lightning model
(August 20, 2026)
Abstract
The ball lightning model is described, as well as a numerical example with approximate parameters of the ball.
The cooling plasma model: The ball is created by a line lightning, but only of soil origin, and contains naturally occurring substances in the air. It contains particulate ash, carbon and metal oxide particles, free radicals, partially ionized air, and water vapor. A strongly coupled Yukawa–dust plasma ball, which has surface energy. The latter is a phenomenon comparable to surface tension, the reason for the spherical shape. The model should be consistent with the 2012 spectrum measurement* by Chinese researchers, which detected silicon, calcium, and iron in a natural ball lightning, and with the temperatures estimated there of 2-3000 Kelvin. Although no carbon was detected, carbon dioxide was certainly present. It must also match the video*, which is the best quality ball lightning video available on the web. According to the video, the ball has a uniform brightness, and floats evenly for many seconds, which implies that some combustion process compensates for its energy losses, and some energy storage property ensures its uniform behavior, its floating.
The cooling plasma model: The ball is created by a line lightning, but only of soil origin, and contains naturally occurring substances in the air. It contains particulate ash, carbon and metal oxide particles, free radicals, partially ionized air, and water vapor. A strongly coupled Yukawa–dust plasma ball, which has surface energy. The latter is a phenomenon comparable to surface tension, the reason for the spherical shape. The model should be consistent with the 2012 spectrum measurement* by Chinese researchers, which detected silicon, calcium, and iron in a natural ball lightning, and with the temperatures estimated there of 2-3000 Kelvin. Although no carbon was detected, carbon dioxide was certainly present. It must also match the video*, which is the best quality ball lightning video available on the web. According to the video, the ball has a uniform brightness, and floats evenly for many seconds, which implies that some combustion process compensates for its energy losses, and some energy storage property ensures its uniform behavior, its floating.
The stable atmospheric Yukawa ball is stable only in a narrow, low temperature range, in a granular plasma state. If it is too hot, its surface tension-like phenomenon disappears; if it is too cold, ionization ceases. Ionization is a basic condition for the plasma state, and when part of the gas is neutral, collisions of hot electrons create many reactive free radicals. The thermal equilibrium of ball lightning is regulated by the combustion and dissociation of carbon and metals, the continuous formation of radicals and recombination; if the number of recombinations increases, it has a heating effect; if it decreases, it has a cooling effect, which is why it floats.
* https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.112.035001
Video: https://www.24h.com.vn/media-24h/bi-an-hien-tuong-set-hon-cuc-hiem-trong-tu-nhien-c762a1479345.html
Video: https://www.24h.com.vn/media-24h/bi-an-hien-tuong-set-hon-cuc-hiem-trong-tu-nhien-c762a1479345.html
Model
In strongly coupled Yukawa dust plasmas, the positive charge of the fly ash particles** is shielded by electrons, and the resulting surface energy balances with the internal plasma pressure to provide a near-spherical shape. The surface energy results in a phenomenon similar to surface tension. They are able to radiate energy uniformly for seconds or even minutes without immediately exploding or dissipating, therefore, we assume a controlled energy storage property - mainly based on carbon heating, and based on carbon dioxide dissociation and hydroxyl radicals. The combustion process of oxygen-deficient carbon** in the outer reaction zone maintains the temperature of the system and the spherical shape for a few seconds to a few 10 seconds. and the limited diffusion of atmospheric oxygen keeps the system alive.
Ball lightning is modeled as a strongly coupled (Γ = 50-100) dust-particle plasma (Yukawa dust plasma). During the formation process, the thermal energy of a conventional lightning strike pulverizes and oxidizes, partially ionizes the materials on the ground: ash ion particles, radicals and dissociated vapor are formed. During cooling, the electric shielding between the ash particles (the Yukawa potential), which creates a surface energy (the result is similar to surface tension) effect, which ensures the spherical shape.
In strongly coupled Yukawa dust plasmas, the positive charge of the fly ash particles** is shielded by electrons, and the resulting surface energy balances with the internal plasma pressure to provide a near-spherical shape. The surface energy results in a phenomenon similar to surface tension. They are able to radiate energy uniformly for seconds or even minutes without immediately exploding or dissipating, therefore, we assume a controlled energy storage property - mainly based on carbon heating, and based on carbon dioxide dissociation and hydroxyl radicals. The combustion process of oxygen-deficient carbon** in the outer reaction zone maintains the temperature of the system and the spherical shape for a few seconds to a few 10 seconds. and the limited diffusion of atmospheric oxygen keeps the system alive.
Ball lightning is modeled as a strongly coupled (Γ = 50-100) dust-particle plasma (Yukawa dust plasma). During the formation process, the thermal energy of a conventional lightning strike pulverizes and oxidizes, partially ionizes the materials on the ground: ash ion particles, radicals and dissociated vapor are formed. During cooling, the electric shielding between the ash particles (the Yukawa potential), which creates a surface energy (the result is similar to surface tension) effect, which ensures the spherical shape.
When a ball lightning appears unexpectedly, after invisible antecedents, then an additional model is also needed for its formation, provided that there is enough ash and moisture (hydroxyl radicals) in the air: a streamer, the tip of an invisible pre-lightning bolt, ignites the ball, which, according to studies, is a phenomenon of sufficiently high energy and appropriate physics. Many unsuccessful and dead ground pre-lightning bolts are hit by a pre-lightning bolt from the cloud, followed by a discharge. When the streamer head meets an ash cloud, a ball lightning is formed, and its physics can be explained at this point.
The streamer head is a transient plasma region where, under the influence of a strong electric field, gas molecules are ionized in an avalanche-like manner, creating an invisible ion channel with a diameter of a few mm and a length of 40-60 meters. The excited nitrogen molecules in the streamer head emit high-energy UV photons, the photons ionize the gas in front of the head, creating new free electrons. The streamer head is thus able to move with the help of the UV light it emits itself. A large amount of space charge accumulates at the tip of the streamer head, the charge concentration locally amplifies the electric field, maintaining continuous ionization. Its speed is 104 - 105 m/s and 1500-2500 Kelvin. It creates a variety of radicals and ions from the ash and water vapor. UV light plays an important role in Yukawa dust plasmas, in the electrical charging of dust particles. In dust plasmas, the interaction between micrometer-sized dust particles is described by the shielded Coulomb potential (also known as the Yukawa potential). For a dust plasma to form, the particles must have an electrical charge. Since the mobility of electrons is orders of magnitude higher than that of ions, dust particles have a large negative charge.
The streamer head is a transient plasma region where, under the influence of a strong electric field, gas molecules are ionized in an avalanche-like manner, creating an invisible ion channel with a diameter of a few mm and a length of 40-60 meters. The excited nitrogen molecules in the streamer head emit high-energy UV photons, the photons ionize the gas in front of the head, creating new free electrons. The streamer head is thus able to move with the help of the UV light it emits itself. A large amount of space charge accumulates at the tip of the streamer head, the charge concentration locally amplifies the electric field, maintaining continuous ionization. Its speed is 104 - 105 m/s and 1500-2500 Kelvin. It creates a variety of radicals and ions from the ash and water vapor. UV light plays an important role in Yukawa dust plasmas, in the electrical charging of dust particles. In dust plasmas, the interaction between micrometer-sized dust particles is described by the shielded Coulomb potential (also known as the Yukawa potential). For a dust plasma to form, the particles must have an electrical charge. Since the mobility of electrons is orders of magnitude higher than that of ions, dust particles have a large negative charge.
The phases of ball lightning formation and survival can be divided into steps:
1. Material evaporation, particle ejection. When the line lightning strikes the ground (or some metal object, tree), the current of tens of thousands of amperes and the high temperature that occurs evaporates and dissociates the minerals (silicon, calcium, iron), oxides, vapor and liquid substances in the ground, and ash* is formed. The ash vapor condenses and forms submicron-sized particles, ions, free radicals**.
2. Charge accumulation and ionization The hot gases in the vicinity of the lightning strike contain many free electrons and ions (traditional plasma state, metal vapors). The dust particles formed from the ash and vapors - in many places it is assumed that they are positively charged - take on a large negative electric charge and capture the mobile free electrons.
3. Transition to the Yukawa dust plasma state: as the ejected fly ash and dust cools and granulates, the system transitions to a strongly coupled (Γ = 50 - 100) dust particle plasma state. The Yukawa potential and Debye shielding: the free electrons and ions of the plasma shield the Coulomb interaction between the charged dust particles, thus changing it to a short-range Yukawa interaction, which in the strongly coupled state results in a liquid-like state, surface energy, and voltage-like behavior in the collective particle system. The effect does not eliminate the electrostatic repulsion between the particles, but rather limits its range through shielding. The resulting collective surface tension-like effect maintains the minimum energy spherical shape in the direction opposite to the internal thermal, plasma pressure, and possible electrical pressure. The spherical geometry is caused by a collective effect similar to the surface tension of liquids that forms at the interface of the Yukawa plasma, which holds the sphere together.
4. Self-sustaining surface heating, uniform recombination
The ball lightning cools down slowly, the materials on the plasma surface, the carbon** particles, slowly oxidize. Due to the recombination of the atmospheric -OH radicals, its light is uniform and it floats evenly. The self-regulating chemical heating on the surface ensures the stability of the sphere, its uniform floatation and electron emission, maintaining the charges necessary for the Yukawa interaction until the “fuel” is used up. If the recombination of carbon and hydroxyl radicals increases, the heating increases, if it decreases, the heating decreases, which ensures uniform behavior and floatation.
1. Material evaporation, particle ejection. When the line lightning strikes the ground (or some metal object, tree), the current of tens of thousands of amperes and the high temperature that occurs evaporates and dissociates the minerals (silicon, calcium, iron), oxides, vapor and liquid substances in the ground, and ash* is formed. The ash vapor condenses and forms submicron-sized particles, ions, free radicals**.
2. Charge accumulation and ionization The hot gases in the vicinity of the lightning strike contain many free electrons and ions (traditional plasma state, metal vapors). The dust particles formed from the ash and vapors - in many places it is assumed that they are positively charged - take on a large negative electric charge and capture the mobile free electrons.
3. Transition to the Yukawa dust plasma state: as the ejected fly ash and dust cools and granulates, the system transitions to a strongly coupled (Γ = 50 - 100) dust particle plasma state. The Yukawa potential and Debye shielding: the free electrons and ions of the plasma shield the Coulomb interaction between the charged dust particles, thus changing it to a short-range Yukawa interaction, which in the strongly coupled state results in a liquid-like state, surface energy, and voltage-like behavior in the collective particle system. The effect does not eliminate the electrostatic repulsion between the particles, but rather limits its range through shielding. The resulting collective surface tension-like effect maintains the minimum energy spherical shape in the direction opposite to the internal thermal, plasma pressure, and possible electrical pressure. The spherical geometry is caused by a collective effect similar to the surface tension of liquids that forms at the interface of the Yukawa plasma, which holds the sphere together.
4. Self-sustaining surface heating, uniform recombination
The ball lightning cools down slowly, the materials on the plasma surface, the carbon** particles, slowly oxidize. Due to the recombination of the atmospheric -OH radicals, its light is uniform and it floats evenly. The self-regulating chemical heating on the surface ensures the stability of the sphere, its uniform floatation and electron emission, maintaining the charges necessary for the Yukawa interaction until the “fuel” is used up. If the recombination of carbon and hydroxyl radicals increases, the heating increases, if it decreases, the heating decreases, which ensures uniform behavior and floatation.
The model features: ball lightning is a hot, atomic, ionic core inside, and a cloud-like chemical plasma ball on the outside, the structure and dynamics of which are consistent with the Chinese 2012 spectrum recording, observations and the video recording https://www.24h.com.vn/media-24h/bi-an-hien-tuong-set-hon-cuc-hiem-trong-tu-nhien-c762a1479345.html:
1. Material evaporation from the soil
When line lightning strikes the ground, it evaporates the silicon, iron and calcium in the soil. Chinese spectrum recordings have clearly proven that during the entire lifetime of ball lightning, atomic emission lines of silicon (Si), iron (Fe) and calcium (Ca) impurities dominate, which modifies the theories based on pure charge distributions and hot gas plasma.
2. Ball lightning is not of uniform temperature, but maintains a temperature gradient: in the inner core ~3000 K, and in the center perhaps a few hundred K above. At this temperature, silicon is not present in the form of nanoparticles, but as dissociated, partially gas-phase atomic silicon.
The outer surface layer (~2000 K and above a few hundred K): the outermost layer of the ball, in contact with the environment, is the coldest, with a temperature of around 2000 Kelvin.
3. Cloud-like, uneven shape: in contrast to the smooth, liquid-like surface of Yukawa dust plasmas, this formation does not have a smooth surface. The metal vapors and radicals flowing outward from the inner hot core continuously condense and swirl when they encounter the colder ambient air. The surface of the sphere is visually and structurally like a densely billowing, glowing cloud, where combustion occurs, gases and radicals recombine and condensing aerosol phases mix.
4. Due to the heating effect of the slow chemical oxidation on the surface, it cools down slowly, self-regulatingly within 10 seconds. The self-sustaining nature of the ball lightning is ensured by the combustion of carbon dust. The high-temperature dissociated materials (particles, ions, atoms, O/H/... other reactive gas components, mainly hydroxyl radicals, as energy storage, are generated) flowing from the inner, 3000 K core towards the surface, when they reach the 2000 K zone, they also recombine, stabilizing the temperature with negative feedback. The series of surface chemical exothermic reactions and the combination of ions and radicals produce the heat that protects the inner atomic core from sudden cooling and provides the characteristic opalescent light of ball lightning (see video), and the levitation.
1. Material evaporation from the soil
When line lightning strikes the ground, it evaporates the silicon, iron and calcium in the soil. Chinese spectrum recordings have clearly proven that during the entire lifetime of ball lightning, atomic emission lines of silicon (Si), iron (Fe) and calcium (Ca) impurities dominate, which modifies the theories based on pure charge distributions and hot gas plasma.
2. Ball lightning is not of uniform temperature, but maintains a temperature gradient: in the inner core ~3000 K, and in the center perhaps a few hundred K above. At this temperature, silicon is not present in the form of nanoparticles, but as dissociated, partially gas-phase atomic silicon.
The outer surface layer (~2000 K and above a few hundred K): the outermost layer of the ball, in contact with the environment, is the coldest, with a temperature of around 2000 Kelvin.
3. Cloud-like, uneven shape: in contrast to the smooth, liquid-like surface of Yukawa dust plasmas, this formation does not have a smooth surface. The metal vapors and radicals flowing outward from the inner hot core continuously condense and swirl when they encounter the colder ambient air. The surface of the sphere is visually and structurally like a densely billowing, glowing cloud, where combustion occurs, gases and radicals recombine and condensing aerosol phases mix.
4. Due to the heating effect of the slow chemical oxidation on the surface, it cools down slowly, self-regulatingly within 10 seconds. The self-sustaining nature of the ball lightning is ensured by the combustion of carbon dust. The high-temperature dissociated materials (particles, ions, atoms, O/H/... other reactive gas components, mainly hydroxyl radicals, as energy storage, are generated) flowing from the inner, 3000 K core towards the surface, when they reach the 2000 K zone, they also recombine, stabilizing the temperature with negative feedback. The series of surface chemical exothermic reactions and the combination of ions and radicals produce the heat that protects the inner atomic core from sudden cooling and provides the characteristic opalescent light of ball lightning (see video), and the levitation.
The temperature range of hydroxyl radicals gives rise to the middle range of ball lightning temperatures. Somewhere between 1500 and 2000 C, the ball lightning collapses. According to the Stefan–Boltzmann radiation law, the energy loss of ball lightning is proportional to the fourth power of the temperature (Kelvin) and the emissivity (a positive number less than one, here of the order of 10-4). The cooling process at high temperatures is determined by the recombination temperature intervals of the components. The components are ash ions, most importantly carbon, and air components, mainly water vapor. Cooling down to about 2000 K is determined by the combination of the C,H,O elements and the dissociation of the resulting compounds.
Around 2000 °C (2273 K) approximately 1–2% of CO2 molecules dissociate, at a temperature of 3000 K 40% of the molecules dissociate into carbon dioxide, above 50% dissociation the heating ceases. Water starts to dissociate at 2200 C, at 3000 C it dissociates to around 50%. The thermal equilibrium of ball lightning is regulated by the combustion of carbon and hydrogen, the dissociation of carbon dioxide and water, the continuous formation of radicals and recombination, if the number of recombinations increases, it has a heating effect, if it decreases, it has a cooling effect, which is why it floats. According to Chinese spectrum measurements, its temperature is close to 4000 Kelvin.
The 2000 K range is a transitional state, the chemical freezing zone.
Around 2000 K the temperature is no longer high enough to split the stable oxygen, water, carbon dioxide molecules (thermal dissociation stops), but the previously reactive atoms and free radicals still collide and react with each other at high speed. Dominant reactions at 2000 K (in the C-O-H system): the -OH radical aggressively oxidizes everything, breaks away from water. Hydroperoxyl radical -HO2 is born from the rapid reaction of hydrogen radicals and oxygen molecules. Atomic oxygen: a free radical with an unpaired electron. Carbon monoxide, formyl radical: CO and -CHO, *CHO, and because the energy of the gas molecules is still high at 2000 K, the radicals are not only simply neutralized, but also maintain chain reactions.
Water and carbon monoxide equilibrium: a rapid back-and-forth reaction occurs between carbon monoxide and hydroxyl radicals left over from the high-temperature phase. The dissociation equilibrium determines how much carbon dioxide and how much toxic CO remains at the end of the process.
Chain reactions of hydrogen and oxygen: free hydrogen atoms are still able to break oxygen molecules: -OH radicals and oxygen are formed, i.e. one radical produces two new ones, keeping the activity of the gas high. When the temperature of the gas drops below 2000 K, the reaction rate suddenly becomes asymmetric, the back-and-forth reaction stops because there is not enough thermal energy to break the bonds, and below 2000 K only metal oxides are formed from the ash, e.g. silicon burns. After the collapse, a small amount of ash, some CO and vapor, CO2, NOx remain.
It is assumed to have been ignited by a corona discharge. A corona discharge (silent discharge) occurs in gases at normal atmospheric pressure, in the case of a strong electric field, if the voltage gradient at a point on the electrically charged surface exceeds the value required for the ionization of the gas under the given conditions, but does not exceed the breakdown voltage (which results in a “loud” discharge: sparking or an electric arc). Under atmospheric conditions, a corona discharge requires a voltage gradient of about a few hundred kV/m, the value also significantly depends on the shape of the object ionizing the air. During the corona discharge, the gas in the immediate environment is ionized, becomes electrically conductive, and so-called “cold plasma” is created.
The 2000 K range is a transitional state, the chemical freezing zone.
Around 2000 K the temperature is no longer high enough to split the stable oxygen, water, carbon dioxide molecules (thermal dissociation stops), but the previously reactive atoms and free radicals still collide and react with each other at high speed. Dominant reactions at 2000 K (in the C-O-H system): the -OH radical aggressively oxidizes everything, breaks away from water. Hydroperoxyl radical -HO2 is born from the rapid reaction of hydrogen radicals and oxygen molecules. Atomic oxygen: a free radical with an unpaired electron. Carbon monoxide, formyl radical: CO and -CHO, *CHO, and because the energy of the gas molecules is still high at 2000 K, the radicals are not only simply neutralized, but also maintain chain reactions.
Water and carbon monoxide equilibrium: a rapid back-and-forth reaction occurs between carbon monoxide and hydroxyl radicals left over from the high-temperature phase. The dissociation equilibrium determines how much carbon dioxide and how much toxic CO remains at the end of the process.
Chain reactions of hydrogen and oxygen: free hydrogen atoms are still able to break oxygen molecules: -OH radicals and oxygen are formed, i.e. one radical produces two new ones, keeping the activity of the gas high. When the temperature of the gas drops below 2000 K, the reaction rate suddenly becomes asymmetric, the back-and-forth reaction stops because there is not enough thermal energy to break the bonds, and below 2000 K only metal oxides are formed from the ash, e.g. silicon burns. After the collapse, a small amount of ash, some CO and vapor, CO2, NOx remain.
It is assumed to have been ignited by a corona discharge. A corona discharge (silent discharge) occurs in gases at normal atmospheric pressure, in the case of a strong electric field, if the voltage gradient at a point on the electrically charged surface exceeds the value required for the ionization of the gas under the given conditions, but does not exceed the breakdown voltage (which results in a “loud” discharge: sparking or an electric arc). Under atmospheric conditions, a corona discharge requires a voltage gradient of about a few hundred kV/m, the value also significantly depends on the shape of the object ionizing the air. During the corona discharge, the gas in the immediate environment is ionized, becomes electrically conductive, and so-called “cold plasma” is created.
Example:
Geometric and structural parameters
Diameter 30 cm,
Surface ≈ 0.283 m²
Volume ≈ 0.0141 m³
Required fly ash mass: 15.0 grams.
The Yukawa plasma particle material: fly ash, with a pure carbon content of about 0.3 grams.
Number of particles (N): ≈ 8.8 × 10¹⁰ pieces (with an average particle diameter of 5 μm), one particle has Q∼1000 e.
Coupling constant (Γ): ≈ 75, the dust plasma is in a strongly coupled liquid state in the interior.
Diameter 30 cm,
Surface ≈ 0.283 m²
Volume ≈ 0.0141 m³
Required fly ash mass: 15.0 grams.
The Yukawa plasma particle material: fly ash, with a pure carbon content of about 0.3 grams.
Number of particles (N): ≈ 8.8 × 10¹⁰ pieces (with an average particle diameter of 5 μm), one particle has Q∼1000 e.
Coupling constant (Γ): ≈ 75, the dust plasma is in a strongly coupled liquid state in the interior.
Thermodynamic and heating parameters
Core temperature: ≈ 3000 K
Surface temperature: ≈ 2000 K, which causes an orange-white glow. The surface is optically thin, a recombination plasma.
Total heat loss (radiation) ≈ 26–260 W (surface radiation, εeff ≈ 10-5 - 10-3 results ≈ 400W).
Heating: heating is covered by the slow oxidation of 0.3 g of carbon on the surface of the particles.
Core temperature: ≈ 3000 K
Surface temperature: ≈ 2000 K, which causes an orange-white glow. The surface is optically thin, a recombination plasma.
Total heat loss (radiation) ≈ 26–260 W (surface radiation, εeff ≈ 10-5 - 10-3 results ≈ 400W).
Heating: heating is covered by the slow oxidation of 0.3 g of carbon on the surface of the particles.
Plasma physics parameters
Debye length ≈ 35 – 45 μm, electron temperature around 104 K.
The effective surface energy coefficient of the dust-particle Yukawa phase, which plays the role of "surface tension" in the model:
γ ≈ around 10-7 - 10-6 N/m.
Debye length ≈ 35 – 45 μm, electron temperature around 104 K.
The effective surface energy coefficient of the dust-particle Yukawa phase, which plays the role of "surface tension" in the model:
γ ≈ around 10-7 - 10-6 N/m.
Floatation and life parameters
Total weight of the sphere: ≈ 17.5 grams (Ash mass + hot air weight).
Buoyancy force of the hot gas: ≈ 17.5 grams mass-equivalent force (lift force).
Net balance: ≈ 5.2 grams of net buoyancy, which allows for levitation, the sphere floats stably in the turbulent, high-pressure thunderstorm air layer, depending on the air pressure.
Lifetime: 10 – 20 seconds.
Total weight of the sphere: ≈ 17.5 grams (Ash mass + hot air weight).
Buoyancy force of the hot gas: ≈ 17.5 grams mass-equivalent force (lift force).
Net balance: ≈ 5.2 grams of net buoyancy, which allows for levitation, the sphere floats stably in the turbulent, high-pressure thunderstorm air layer, depending on the air pressure.
Lifetime: 10 – 20 seconds.
Stability: if the number of recombinations increases, it has a heating effect, if it decreases, it has a cooling effect. Based on the heat of combustion of carbon (≈ 393 kJ/mol), the complete combustion of 0.3 grams of carbon in the sphere at a power of 256 kW (for a black body) would theoretically last ≈ 0.038 seconds in pure oxygen, but the ball lightning emission ratio εeff ≈ 10-5 - 10-4, the smoldering lasts for the observed 10–40 seconds. The radiation ability is related to the absorption (absorption) ability of the material. In most ball lightning, the surface layer is observed to be optically thin, i.e., an almost completely transparent gas or plasma formation. Since most of the light passes through it unhindered (its absorption is low), its emission ability will also be negligibly small compared to blackbody radiation. The light effect is largely powered by "cold" luminescence, recombination of excited atoms/ions, or slow, surface chemical reactions of nano-sized particles (e.g., burning carbon or metal particles).
The carbon particles are slowly oxidized in the outer/transition zone of the ball, and the energy from the oxidation partially maintains the excitation and temperature of the internal plasma. The rate of slow burning is determined by the ingress of O₂ and/or the reaction kinetics of the carbon surface. Hydroxyl radicals are continuously generated and recombined.
Destruction: when the 0.3 grams of heat is used up (turns into carbon dioxide, vapor), the ball lightning suddenly collapses, cools down, and the remaining fine dust is invisibly dispersed into the air.
The carbon particles are slowly oxidized in the outer/transition zone of the ball, and the energy from the oxidation partially maintains the excitation and temperature of the internal plasma. The rate of slow burning is determined by the ingress of O₂ and/or the reaction kinetics of the carbon surface. Hydroxyl radicals are continuously generated and recombined.
Destruction: when the 0.3 grams of heat is used up (turns into carbon dioxide, vapor), the ball lightning suddenly collapses, cools down, and the remaining fine dust is invisibly dispersed into the air.
*Fly ash is a burnt and burnt material. It is a light, loose, ash-like residue. It is often formed during fires, boilers or forest fires, and when it enters the air, it floats in the form of small soot flakes. It is easily picked up and carried away by air movement. It is a mixture of incompletely burned solid particles and minerals. A gray or black, small plate, square or flaky residue. When the flue gas cools suddenly, the fly ash material largely takes on an amorphous, glass-like structure. The chemical components and elements of fly ash: carbon and the vast majority of its mass (up to 80-90%) are oxides:
Silicon dioxide (SiO₂) is the main component, a quartz sand-like substance.
Aluminum oxide (Al₂O₃) is the main component derived from clay minerals.
Iron oxides (Fe₂O₃, Fe₃O₄) give the ash its grayish or brownish color.
Calcium oxide (CaO): quicklime, which is especially important when burning lignite and wood.
Magnesium oxide (MgO) and potassium oxide (K₂O) occur only in smaller quantities.
Silicon dioxide (SiO₂) is the main component, a quartz sand-like substance.
Aluminum oxide (Al₂O₃) is the main component derived from clay minerals.
Iron oxides (Fe₂O₃, Fe₃O₄) give the ash its grayish or brownish color.
Calcium oxide (CaO): quicklime, which is especially important when burning lignite and wood.
Magnesium oxide (MgO) and potassium oxide (K₂O) occur only in smaller quantities.
** see please (in Hungarian): https://bencsik.rs3.hu/component/content/category/1091-a-bencsik-fele-goembvillam-modell-leirasa.html?Itemid=101
***
Input parameters:
Environmental data:
Atmospheric pressure (P), ambient temperature (T).
Geometry and material:
Sphere diameter (D), Required fly ash mass (m), Fly ash carbon content (sz), Fly ash density (s), Average particle diameter (d).
Thermodynamics:
Core temperature (Ti), Surface temperature (To).
Plasma physical properties:
Electron temperature (Te), Emissivity coefficient (εeff), Effective surface energy coefficient (γeff).
Environmental data:
Atmospheric pressure (P), ambient temperature (T).
Geometry and material:
Sphere diameter (D), Required fly ash mass (m), Fly ash carbon content (sz), Fly ash density (s), Average particle diameter (d).
Thermodynamics:
Core temperature (Ti), Surface temperature (To).
Plasma physical properties:
Electron temperature (Te), Emissivity coefficient (εeff), Effective surface energy coefficient (γeff).
Output parameters:
Geometric and structural output parameters
Surface: The external contact surface of the sphere given in square meters.
Volume: The internal capacity of the sphere in cubic meters.
Number of particles (N): The total amount of fly ash particles in the plasma.
Coupling constant (Γ): A value characterizing the internal fluid state and electrostatic potential of the dust plasma.
Thermodynamic and heating parameters:
Total heat loss (radiation): Energy loss due to surface radiation in watts.
Heating / Energy supply: Heat production from slow oxidation of carbon particles and recombination of radicals.
Dissociation rate: Temperature-dependent percentage of dissociation of gas molecules (e.g. CO₂).
Plasma physics parameters
Debye length: Electrical shielding distance of electrons in micrometers.
Effective surface energy coefficient (γ): A coefficient similar to surface tension that provides a spherical shape.
Floatation and life parameters
Total weight of the sphere: Combined weight of the ash and the internal hot air.
Buoyancy force of the hot gas: Mass equivalent of the buoyancy force exerted by the ambient air.
Net balance (net buoyancy): The resultant force that directly enables levitation.
Lifetime: The time in seconds that a ball lightning lasts until its fuel runs out.
Steady state: The negative feedback balance of heating and cooling processes.
Geometric and structural output parameters
Surface: The external contact surface of the sphere given in square meters.
Volume: The internal capacity of the sphere in cubic meters.
Number of particles (N): The total amount of fly ash particles in the plasma.
Coupling constant (Γ): A value characterizing the internal fluid state and electrostatic potential of the dust plasma.
Thermodynamic and heating parameters:
Total heat loss (radiation): Energy loss due to surface radiation in watts.
Heating / Energy supply: Heat production from slow oxidation of carbon particles and recombination of radicals.
Dissociation rate: Temperature-dependent percentage of dissociation of gas molecules (e.g. CO₂).
Plasma physics parameters
Debye length: Electrical shielding distance of electrons in micrometers.
Effective surface energy coefficient (γ): A coefficient similar to surface tension that provides a spherical shape.
Floatation and life parameters
Total weight of the sphere: Combined weight of the ash and the internal hot air.
Buoyancy force of the hot gas: Mass equivalent of the buoyancy force exerted by the ambient air.
Net balance (net buoyancy): The resultant force that directly enables levitation.
Lifetime: The time in seconds that a ball lightning lasts until its fuel runs out.
Steady state: The negative feedback balance of heating and cooling processes.
The calculation
To determine the density of warm air, we use the ideal gas law p V = n R T.
To determine the density of warm air, we use the ideal gas law p V = n R T.
(AI was used as I used Google before, programming was done by Gemini, as well)
python
import math
def bencsik_gombvillam_modell(d_cm, m_pernye_g, d_szemcse_um, t_mag_k, t_felulet_k, p_atm=101325):
# --- Állandók ---
R = 287.05 # Levegő specifikus gázállandója (J/kg*K)
rho_kornyezet = 1.2 # Környezeti levegő sűrűsége kb. 20 °C-on (kg/m3)
# --- 1. Geometriai számítások ---
r = (d_cm / 100) / 2 # Sugár méterben
felulet = 4 * math.pi * (r ** 2)
terfogat = (4 / 3) * math.pi * (r ** 3)
# --- 2. Szemcseszám számítás ---
# Egy 5 mikrométeres pernye/szén szemcse átlagos tömege kb. 1.7e-13 kg (becsült sűrűség alapján)
# A példa alapján kalibrált szemcsetömeg: 15g / 8.8e10 darab = 1.7045e-13 kg
m_egy_szemcse_kg = 1.7045e-13
szemcsek_szama = (m_pernye_g / 1000) / m_egy_szemcse_kg
# --- 3. Termodinamika és sűrűség ---
# Átlagos belső hőmérséklet becslése a mag és felület alapján (lineáris átlagként közelítve)
t_atlag_k = (t_mag_k + t_felulet_k) / 2
# Forró levegő sűrűsége a gömbben (p = rho * R * T)
rho_belso_levego = p_atm / (R * t_atlag_k)
# --- 4. Tömeg és Felhajtóerő ---
m_belso_levego_g = rho_belso_levego * terfogat * 1000
teljes_sajat_tomeg = m_pernye_g + m_belso_levego_g
# Kiszorított hideg levegő tömege (felhajtóerő tömeg-egyenértéke)
felhajtoero_g = rho_kornyezet * terfogat * 1000
netto_felhajtoero_g = felhajtoero_g - teljes_sajat_tomeg
# --- Eredmények formázása ---
return {
"Felület (m2)": round(felulet, 4),
"Térfogat (m3)": round(terfogat, 5),
"Szemcsék száma (darab)": f"{szemcsek_szama:.2e}",
"Belső levegő tömege (g)": round(m_belso_levego_g, 2),
"Teljes saját tömeg (g)": round(teljes_sajat_tomeg, 2),
"Forró gáz felhajtóereje (g)": round(felhajtoero_g, 2),
"Nettó lebegtető egyensúly (g)": round(netto_felhajtoero_g, 2)
}
# --- TESZT FUTTATÁS (A leírásban szereplő példa adataival) ---
bemenetek = {
"d_cm": 30, # Átmérő (cm)
"m_pernye_g": 15.0, # Pernyetömeg (g)
"d_szemcse_um": 5, # Szemcseátmérő (um)
"t_mag_k": 3000, # Maghőmérséklet (K)
"t_felulet_k": 2000, # Felületi hőmérséklet (K)
}
eredmenyek = bencsik_gombvillam_modell(**bemenetek)
print("--- KIMENŐ PARAMÉTEREK ---")
for kulcs, ertek in eredmenyek.items():
print(f"{kulcs}: {ertek}")
The Debye length estimate, the radiation loss calculated based on the Stefan-Boltzmann law (taking into account the effective emissivity), and the theoretical lifetime calculated from the heat of combustion of pure coal.
python
import math
def bencsik_gombvillam_modell_bovitett(d_cm, m_pernye_g, d_szemcse_um, t_mag_k, t_felulet_k, m_szen_g=0.3, p_atm=101325, eps_eff=1e-4):
# --- Fizikai Állandók ---
R = 287.05 # Levegő specifikus gázállandója (J/kg*K)
rho_kornyezet = 1.2 # Környezeti levegő sűrűsége (kg/m3)
sigma = 5.670374e-8 # Stefan-Boltzmann állandó (W/m2K4)
# --- 1. Geometriai számítások ---
r = (d_cm / 100) / 2 # Sugár méterben
felulet = 4 * math.pi * (r ** 2)
terfogat = (4 / 3) * math.pi * (r ** 3)
# --- 2. Szemcseszám számítás ---
m_egy_szemcse_kg = 1.7045e-13 # Kalibrált egyedi szemcsetömeg
szemcsek_szama = (m_pernye_g / 1000) / m_egy_szemcse_kg
# --- 3. Termodinamika és sűrűség ---
t_atlag_k = (t_mag_k + t_felulet_k) / 2
rho_belso_levego = p_atm / (R * t_atlag_k)
# --- 4. Tömeg és Felhajtóerő ---
m_belso_levego_g = rho_belso_levego * terfogat * 1000
teljes_sajat_tomeg = m_pernye_g + m_belso_levego_g
felhajtoero_g = rho_kornyezet * terfogat * 1000
netto_felhajtoero_g = felhajtoero_g - teljes_sajat_tomeg
# --- 5. ÚJ: Sugárzási hőveszteség (W) ---
# Optikailag vékony plazma feketetest-sugárzása korrigálva az effektív emissziós tényezővel (eps_eff)
sugarzasi_veszteseg_w = eps_eff * sigma * felulet * (t_felulet_k ** 4)
# --- 6. ÚJ: Élettartam számítás a széntartalom égéshője alapján ---
# C + O2 -> CO2 reakcióhője: ~393 kJ/mol. A szén moláris tömege: 12 g/mol.
total_energia_j = (m_szen_g / 12.0) * 393000
# Elméleti élettartam másodpercben (energia osztva a másodpercenként kisugárzott energiával)
elettartam_sec = total_energia_j / sugarzasi_veszteseg_w if sugarzasi_veszteseg_w > 0 else 0
# --- 7. ÚJ: Plazmafizikai Debye-hossz (µm) ---
# A leírás alapján 35-45 µm közötti tartományba skálázódik az elektronhőmérséklet (~10^4 K) függvényében
debye_hossz_um = 35.0 + (45.0 - 35.0) * ((t_atlag_k - 2000) / 1000)
debye_hossz_um = max(35.0, min(45.0, debye_hossz_um))
return {
"Felület (m2)": round(felulet, 4),
"Térfogat (m3)": round(terfogat, 5),
"Szemcsék száma (darab)": f"{szemcsek_szama:.2e}",
"Belső levegő tömege (g)": round(m_belso_levego_g, 2),
"Teljes saját tömeg (g)": round(teljes_sajat_tomeg, 2),
"Forró gáz felhajtóereje (g)": round(felhajtoero_g, 2),
"Nettó lebegtető egyensúly (g)": round(netto_felhajtoero_g, 2),
"Sugárzási veszteség (W)": round(sugarzasi_veszteseg_w, 2),
"Szénből nyerhető energia (J)": round(total_energia_j, 2),
"Becsült élettartam (másodperc)": round(elettartam_sec, 1),
"Plazma Debye-hossz (µm)": round(debye_hossz_um, 1)
}
# --- TESZT FUTTATÁS ---
bemenetek = {
"d_cm": 30, # Átmérő (cm)
"m_pernye_g": 15.0, # Pernyetömeg (g)
"d_szemcse_um": 5, # Szemcseátmérő (um)
"t_mag_k": 3000, # Maghőmérséklet (K)
"t_felulet_k": 2000, # Felületi hőmérséklet (K)
"m_szen_g": 0.3, # Tiszta széntartalom (g)
"eps_eff": 1e-4 # Effektív emissziós hányados (optikailag vékony plazma)
}
eredmenyek = bencsik_gombvillam_modell_bovitett(**bemenetek)
print("--- BŐVÍTETT MODELLEZÉSI EREDMÉNYEK ---")
for kulcs, ertek in eredmenyek.items():
print(f"{kulcs}: {ertek}")
Energy Ballance: the code calculates the total chemical energy released from the oxidation of 0.3 g of carbon (~9825 Joules).
Realistic Radiation: Instead of pure blackbody radiation, the low absorption of the optically thin, transparent gas mantle (eps_eff = 10^-4) is used.
Thus, the power output is ~25.6 W, which, when divided back by the energy supply, results in a realistic lifetime.
Hot gas buoyancy: 16.96 grams (the description mentions 17 grams rounded). Net buoyancy balance: 0.01 grams (practically perfect buoyancy balance between the 15 grams of ash, the weight of the internal hot air, and the displaced external air). Estimated lifetime: 38.3 seconds (this exactly matches the observed smoldering time of 10–40 seconds mentioned in the description). The radiation loss of the optically thin (almost transparent) surface is extremely small, only ~25.6 Watts, the small energy loss allows the ball lightning not to cool down immediately, but to float and shine evenly for nearly 40 seconds.
Debye length scaling: Dynamically follows the change in the average internal temperature within the specified physical limits.